Emerging Effects from CCSS

I am now 3-1/2 months into the 2017-18 school year and I can finally say I am seeing significant results from the move toward Common Core State Standards for math (CCSS-M) in my Algebra I students.  When Missouri voted out CCSS, the math standards were mostly preserved, but we have been relatively slow in implementing them.

Improved Procedural Skills

My Algebra I students, in general, have always arrived with very weak understanding of fraction operations, having memorized and confused many tricks to solve problems on math tests.  This year I hoped to see stronger skills, knowing my district has been working hard to  improve and align instruction to MO math standards. After verifying with the lower grade teachers they were using fraction sticks, I bought a set of magnets.


When a fraction appears in a problem I am discussing with my students, I can slide down a few sticks, and the understanding rapidly clicks into place.  In prior years, my students would say, “KFC!” (keep-flip-change) and flip their fractions in contexts where that trick doesn’t work.  No one has mentioned chicken this year, Kentucky Fried or otherwise.

In 2014-2015 NCTM published, 13 Rules that Expire and 12 Math Rules that Expire in the Middle Grades.  Around the same time, Tina Cordone released, Nixthetricks.com which has been downloaded around 50,000 times from Amazon.  No doubt these publications have run the math-ed circuit, adding much support the CCSS-M mission of balancing procedure, concept (understanding, connection, big picture), and application.  Fraction sense is one of the results I had hoped for when I first read the draft.  It is exhilarating to witness the improvement in my own classroom, but there are other effects I find equally exciting.

More Interesting and Informative Instruction

Many of the CCSS seem to inspire student-centered instructional methods.  With fewer standards, there is more time to go in depth.  Standards that require student explanations are perfect for whole-class discussions, Kagan & McREL strategies, and innumerable others that engage and challenge students in ways that traditional direct  or repetitious instruction cannot. After trying some of those methods and seeing improved retention, I volunteered to pilot an inquiry-based ebook with my students this year.  Inquiry-based learning requires a major shift in teaching strategies from telling to coaching. The effect on my students and classroom environment has been transformational, building ambition, retention, empathy, and 21st-century career skills.  When students finish early, they are allowed to work ahead with Khan or on particular skills I assign to individual students as I detect weaknesses in their work.  They find joy as they notice themselves growing.  Today’s between-class art looked like this on my whiteboard:cpmNeedless to say, not one student has asked me this year if they would ever use this stuff in real life.

It is often difficult for high school teachers to envision inquiry-based learning in a math classroom, not just because it is so different, but because of sincerely held beliefs about what students need to learn going into college.  A recent question posed on NCTM’s discussion board, for example, asked about why we need to teach Descarte’s Rule of Signs.  I surmised that teacher did not realize CCSS omit Descartes and other extraneous, tedious topics to make room for deep explorations into modeling problems.  It is extremely helpful to have high quality instructional materials that align well with the CCSS to be able to emphasis truly important concepts.  In another post, Chief CCSS writer Dr. William McCallum helped me compile a list of  topics that would best be abandoned in Algebra 2.  The list is linked near the end:

Just as there has been opposition to CCSS, there is opposition to inquiry-based learning. There are some  good reasons to be cautious.  However, when inquiry instruction is done well, I believe it is the key to meeting the needs of today’s students.  Like CCSS, it will probably take many years before the benefits become well understood.  In my thinking, it is worth the wait.



2 thoughts on “Emerging Effects from CCSS

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s